Jump to content

Exeggcute used its Propagation Ability six times in one turn


KadiSuperwoman
 Share

Recommended Posts

Line 97 thru 110 is where yeska08 used Exeggcute's ability more than once per turn

Game Log Output Begins Here:
    1. yeska08 flipped 1 coin(s), resulting in 1 heads and 0 tails, for Beginning of Game.
    2. It is now yeska08's turn (Turn #1).
    3. yeska08 drew a card.
    4. Dragon37110 drew Carbink.
    5. yeska08 drew a card.
    6. Dragon37110 drew Pokémon Communication.
    7. yeska08 drew a card.
    8. Dragon37110 drew Apricorn Maker.
    9. yeska08 drew a card.
    10. Dragon37110 drew Fighting Energy.
    11. yeska08 drew a card.
    12. Dragon37110 drew Fighting Energy.
    13. yeska08 drew a card.
    14. Dragon37110 drew Marshadow & Machamp-GX.
    15. yeska08 drew a card.
    16. Dragon37110 drew Tympole.
    17. Marshadow & Machamp-GX became Dragon37110's new Active Pokémon.
    18. Dragon37110 put Carbink onto the Bench.
    19. Dragon37110 put Tympole onto the Bench.
    20. yeska08 drew a card.
    21. yeska08 attached a Float Stone to Snorlax V.
    22. yeska08 played Quick Ball.
    23. yeska08 drew Tapu Lele-GX.
    24. yeska08 put Tapu Lele-GX onto the Bench.
    25. yeska08's Tapu Lele-GX used its Wonder Tag Ability.
    26. yeska08 drew Marnie.
    27. yeska08 attached a Double Colorless Energy to Tapu Lele-GX.
    28. It is now Dragon37110's turn (Turn #2).
    29. Dragon37110 drew Strong Energy.
    30. Dragon37110 attached a Strong Energy to Marshadow & Machamp-GX.
    31. Dragon37110 played Apricorn Maker.
    32. Dragon37110 drew Master Ball.
    33. Dragon37110 drew Nest Ball.
    34. Dragon37110 played Nest Ball.
    35. Dragon37110 put Phanpy onto the Bench.
    36. Dragon37110 played Master Ball.
    37. Dragon37110 drew Palpitoad.
    38. It is now yeska08's turn (Turn #3).
    39. yeska08 drew a card.
    40. yeska08's Snorlax V retreated.
    41. Tapu Lele-GX became yeska08's new Active Pokémon.
    42. yeska08 attached a Double Colorless Energy to Tapu Lele-GX.
    43. yeska08 played Marnie.
    44. yeska08 drew a card.
    45. yeska08 drew a card.
    46. yeska08 drew a card.
    47. yeska08 drew a card.
    48. yeska08 drew a card.
    49. Dragon37110 drew Pokémon Communication.
    50. Dragon37110 drew Stonjourner V.
    51. Dragon37110 drew Karate Belt.
    52. Dragon37110 drew Martial Arts Dojo.
    53. yeska08 put Zorua onto the Bench.
    54. yeska08 played Battle Compressor Team Flare Gear.
    55. yeska08's Tapu Lele-GX used Energy Drive and did 100 damage to Dragon37110's Marshadow & Machamp-GX.
    56. It is now Dragon37110's turn (Turn #4).
    57. Dragon37110 drew Strong Energy.
    58. Dragon37110 attached a Strong Energy to Marshadow & Machamp-GX.
    59. Dragon37110 played Martial Arts Dojo.
    60. Dragon37110 played Pokémon Communication.
    61. Dragon37110 drew Donphan.
    62. Dragon37110 put Donphan onto the Bench.
    63. Dragon37110's Phanpy evolved into Donphan.
    64. Dragon37110 attached a Karate Belt to Donphan.
    65. Dragon37110's Marshadow & Machamp-GX used Revenge and did 70 damage to yeska08's Tapu Lele-GX.
    66. It is now yeska08's turn (Turn #5).
    67. yeska08 drew a card.
    68. yeska08 put Tapu Lele-GX onto the Bench.
    69. yeska08's Tapu Lele-GX used its Wonder Tag Ability.
    70. yeska08 drew Guzma & Hala.
    71. yeska08 played Guzma & Hala.
    72. yeska08 drew Sky Field.
    73. yeska08 played Sky Field.
    74. yeska08's Tapu Lele-GX used Energy Drive and did 120 damage to Dragon37110's Marshadow & Machamp-GX.
    75. It is now Dragon37110's turn (Turn #6).
    76. Dragon37110 drew Palpitoad.
    77. Dragon37110 put Palpitoad onto the Bench.
    78. Dragon37110's Tympole evolved into Palpitoad.
    79. Dragon37110's Marshadow & Machamp-GX used Revenge and did 70 damage to yeska08's Tapu Lele-GX.
    80. It is now yeska08's turn (Turn #7).
    81. yeska08 drew a card.
    82. yeska08 played Scoop Up Cyclone.
    83. Tapu Lele-GX became yeska08's new Active Pokémon.
    84. yeska08 attached a Double Colorless Energy to Tapu Lele-GX.
    85. yeska08 put Zorua onto the Bench.
    86. yeska08 played Colress.
    87. yeska08 drew a card.
    88. yeska08 drew a card.
    89. yeska08 drew a card.
    90. yeska08 drew a card.
    91. yeska08 drew a card.
    92. yeska08 drew a card.
    93. yeska08 put Alolan Grimer onto the Bench.
    94. yeska08 put Zoroark-GX onto the Bench.
    95. yeska08's Zorua evolved into Zoroark-GX.
    96. yeska08 put Snorlax V onto the Bench.
    97. yeska08's Exeggcute used its Propagation Ability.
    98. yeska08 played Quick Ball.
    99. yeska08 drew Sudowoodo.
    100. yeska08 put Sudowoodo onto the Bench.
    101. yeska08's Exeggcute used its Propagation Ability.
    102. yeska08's Exeggcute used its Propagation Ability.
    103. yeska08 played Ultra Ball.
    104. yeska08 drew Zoroark-GX.
    105. yeska08's Exeggcute used its Propagation Ability.
    106. yeska08's Zoroark-GX used its Trade Ability.
    107. yeska08 drew a card.
    108. yeska08 drew a card.
    109. yeska08's Exeggcute used its Propagation Ability.
    110. yeska08's Exeggcute used its Propagation Ability.
    111. yeska08 played Ultra Ball.
    112. yeska08 drew Crobat V.
    113. yeska08 put Crobat V onto the Bench.
    114. yeska08 drew a card.
    115. yeska08 drew a card.
    116. yeska08 drew a card.
    117. yeska08's Tapu Lele-GX used Energy Drive and did 80 damage to Dragon37110's Marshadow & Machamp-GX.
    118. Dragon37110's Marshadow & Machamp-GX was Knocked Out.
    119. yeska08 took a Prize card.
    120. yeska08 took a Prize card.
    121. yeska08 took a Prize card.
    122. Donphan became Dragon37110's new Active Pokémon.
    123. It is now Dragon37110's turn (Turn #8).
    124. Dragon37110 drew Double Colorless Energy.
    125. Dragon37110 attached a Double Colorless Energy to Palpitoad.
    126. Dragon37110's Donphan used Earthquake and did 120 damage to yeska08's Tapu Lele-GX.
    127. Dragon37110's Donphan used Earthquake and did 20 damage to Dragon37110's Carbink.
    128. Dragon37110's Donphan used Earthquake and did 20 damage to Dragon37110's Palpitoad.
    129. It is now yeska08's turn (Turn #9).
    130. yeska08 drew a card.
    131. yeska08 put Zoroark-GX onto the Bench.
    132. yeska08's Zorua evolved into Zoroark-GX.
    133. yeska08's Exeggcute used its Propagation Ability.
    134. yeska08's Exeggcute used its Propagation Ability.
    135. yeska08's Zoroark-GX used its Trade Ability.
    136. yeska08 drew a card.
    137. yeska08 drew a card.
    138. yeska08's Zoroark-GX used its Trade Ability.
    139. yeska08 drew a card.
    140. yeska08 drew a card.
    141. yeska08 attached a Float Stone to Tapu Lele-GX.
    142. yeska08 put Alolan Muk onto the Bench.
    143. yeska08's Alolan Grimer evolved into Alolan Muk.
    144. yeska08 played VS Seeker.
    145. yeska08 attached a Triple Acceleration Energy to Zoroark-GX.
    146. yeska08 played Colress.
    147. yeska08 drew a card.
    148. yeska08 drew a card.
    149. yeska08 drew a card.
    150. yeska08 drew a card.
    151. yeska08 drew a card.
    152. yeska08 drew a card.
    153. yeska08 drew a card.
    154. yeska08 drew a card.
    155. yeska08 drew a card.
    156. yeska08's Tapu Lele-GX used Energy Drive and did 40 damage to Dragon37110's Donphan.
    157. It is now Dragon37110's turn (Turn #10).
    158. Dragon37110 drew Pokémon Fan Club.
    159. Dragon37110 played Pokémon Fan Club.
    160. Dragon37110 drew Zygarde.
    161. Dragon37110 drew Stonjourner V.
    162. Dragon37110 put Stonjourner V onto the Bench.
    163. Dragon37110 put Zygarde onto the Bench.
    164. Dragon37110's Donphan used Earthquake and did 120 damage to yeska08's Tapu Lele-GX.
    165. Dragon37110's Donphan used Earthquake and did 20 damage to Dragon37110's Carbink.
    166. Dragon37110's Donphan used Earthquake and did 20 damage to Dragon37110's Zygarde.
    167. Dragon37110's Donphan used Earthquake and did 20 damage to Dragon37110's Palpitoad.
    168. Dragon37110's Donphan used Earthquake and did 20 damage to Dragon37110's Stonjourner V.
    169. yeska08's Tapu Lele-GX was Knocked Out.
    170. Dragon37110 took a Prize card.
    171. Dragon37110 took a Prize card.
    172. Zoroark-GX became yeska08's new Active Pokémon.
    173. It is now yeska08's turn (Turn #11).
    174. yeska08 drew a card.
    175. yeska08 attached a Triple Acceleration Energy to Zoroark-GX.
    176. yeska08's Zoroark-GX used its Trade Ability.
    177. yeska08 drew a card.
    178. yeska08 drew a card.
    179. yeska08 played Ultra Ball.
    180. yeska08 drew Snorlax VMAX.
    181. yeska08 put Snorlax VMAX onto the Bench.
    182. yeska08 attached a Float Stone to Snorlax VMAX.
    183. yeska08's Snorlax V evolved into Snorlax VMAX.
    184. yeska08's Zoroark-GX used its Trade Ability.
    185. yeska08 drew a card.
    186. yeska08 drew a card.
    187. yeska08's Zoroark-GX used Riotous Beating and did 140 damage to Dragon37110's Donphan.
    188. Dragon37110's Donphan was Knocked Out.
    189. yeska08 took a Prize card.
    190. Carbink became Dragon37110's new Active Pokémon.
    191. It is now Dragon37110's turn (Turn #12).
    192. Dragon37110 drew Fighting Energy.
    193. Dragon37110 attached a Fighting Energy to Palpitoad.
    194. It is now yeska08's turn (Turn #13).
    195. yeska08 drew a card.
    196. yeska08 attached a Triple Acceleration Energy to Zoroark-GX.
    197. yeska08's Zoroark-GX used Riotous Beating and did 140 damage to Dragon37110's Carbink.
    198. Dragon37110's Carbink was Knocked Out.
    199. yeska08 took a Prize card.
    200. Palpitoad became Dragon37110's new Active Pokémon.
    201. It is now Dragon37110's turn (Turn #14).
    202. Dragon37110 drew Pokémon Center Lady.
    203. Dragon37110 attached a Fighting Energy to Palpitoad.
    204. Dragon37110 played Pokémon Center Lady.
    205. Dragon37110's Palpitoad healed for 40.
    206. Dragon37110's Palpitoad used Mini Earthquake and did 120 damage to yeska08's Zoroark-GX.
    207. Dragon37110's Palpitoad used Mini Earthquake and did 10 damage to Dragon37110's Stonjourner V.
    208. Dragon37110's Palpitoad used Mini Earthquake and did 10 damage to Dragon37110's Zygarde.
    209. It is now yeska08's turn (Turn #***.
    210. yeska08 drew a card.
    211. yeska08 attached a Triple Acceleration Energy to Zoroark-GX.
    212. yeska08's Zoroark-GX used Riotous Beating and did 140 damage to Dragon37110's Palpitoad.
    213. Dragon37110's Palpitoad was Knocked Out.
    214. yeska08 took a Prize card.
    215. Your opponent took all of their Prize cards to win the game!

Game Log Output Ends Here

  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

This is not a bug based on the rulings.  Another individual explained it on another similar thread:

 

"When the Exeggcute uses Propagation and goes back into the opponent's hand, it is unknown if the same Exeggcute is discarded again, hence the rule is that since the opponent's hand is a private area (meaning you wouldn't ever know its contents or the game wouldn't have memory of its contents, i.e. even if he only has one hand and that is certain to be Exeggcute, the game state doesn't memorize that) The ability can be used over and over again, even if you can mark the Exeggcute and see it going up and down and up and down over and over again. Hence there is no game bug here, please let me know if I haven't explained this clear enough, I'd be happy to elaborate.

 

For example, Suppose Player A has 3 Minccino (SSH) in play and has Exeggcute and another card in hand, you wouldn't know if he'd be cycling through the Exeggcutes, since it's his hand and you don't have knowledge of his hand (even if you used Lavender Town or something like that, the game state doesn't memorize your knowledge or his hand's cards) hence you could never be sure what he used, hence you can never say that he used the same Exeggcute multiple times, even if you knew he did while standing behind him. Hence he would be able to use all three Minccino's abilities. "

 

Granted I believe it should be limited to 4 times max since a player can only use 4 exeggcute in a deck.

  • Upvote 2
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Not a bug.

 

Quote

Q. If I use Exeggcute's "Propagation" Ability to retrieve it from the Discard Pile into my hand, then use something like Ultra Ball or Computer Search to discard Exeggcute, would I be able to use "Propagation" again to retrieve it from the Discard Pile?
A. Yes, whenever Exeggcute is in the Discard Pile, you may use Propagation during your turn as long as its Ability has not been disabled. (Plasma Freeze FAQ; May 16, 2013 TPCi Rules Team)

 

As has been stated, once the exeggcute goes from a zone of public knowledge (discard pile) to a zone of private knowledge, (hand) the game state "loses track" of it. If you then discard it again, the game considers it a new exeggcute, so you can use the ability again. 

Edited by IceBeamTogetic
reword
  • Upvote 1
Link to comment
Share on other sites

 Share

×
×
  • Create New...