Jump to content
Estradaserg

[CARD] Muk & Alolan Muk-GX (Unbroken Bonds 61) - Muk and Alolan Muk bug

Recommended Posts

Estradaserg

After using severe poison on an opponent, if the opposing Pokémon attacks Muk it will shake off the effect of severe poison and will only receive poison counters according to to whatever the standard is plus other card effects(seviper, etc). I noticed this a few times in other games but thought it was a one time thing, but noticed it happen every time in my most recent game. 

  • Downvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Estradaserg
Spoiler

 

Game Log Output Begins Here:   

Spoiler

 

1. Spenchismo flipped 1 coin(s), resulting in 1 heads and 0 tails, for Beginning of Game.

    2. It is now Estradaserg's turn (Turn #1).

    3. Spenchismo drew a card.

    4. Estradaserg drew Koga's Trap.

    5. Spenchismo drew a card.

    6. Estradaserg drew Muk & Alolan Muk-GX.

    7. Spenchismo drew a card.

    8. Estradaserg drew Virbank City Gym.

    9. Spenchismo drew a card.

    10. Estradaserg drew Rainbow Energy.

    11. Spenchismo drew a card.

    12. Estradaserg drew Grass Energy.

    13. Spenchismo drew a card.

    14. Estradaserg drew Ariados.

    15. Spenchismo drew a card.

    16. Estradaserg drew Grass Energy.

    17. Muk & Alolan Muk-GX became Estradaserg's new Active Pokémon.

    18. Estradaserg drew Grass Energy.

    19. Estradaserg attached a Rainbow Energy to Muk & Alolan Muk-GX.

    20. Estradaserg's Muk & Alolan Muk-GX had 1 damage counter(s) put on it from Rainbow Energy.

    21. Estradaserg played Virbank City Gym.

    22. Estradaserg played Koga's Trap.

    23. Spenchismo's Eevee is now Confused.

    24. Spenchismo's Eevee is now Poisoned.

    25. Spenchismo's Eevee took 30 damage because it was Poisoned.

    26. It is now Spenchismo's turn (Turn #2).

    27. Spenchismo drew a card.

    28. Spenchismo attached a Fairy Energy to Eevee.

    29. Spenchismo's Eevee used its Energy Evolution Ability.

    30. Spenchismo's Eevee is no longer Confused.

    31. Spenchismo's Eevee is no longer Poisoned.

    32. Spenchismo's Eevee evolved into Sylveon-GX.

    33. Spenchismo played Plumeria.

    34. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX used its Magical Ribbon attack.

    35. Spenchismo drew a card.

    36. Spenchismo drew a card.

    37. Spenchismo drew a card.

    38. It is now Estradaserg's turn (Turn #3).

    39. Estradaserg drew Rainbow Energy.

    40. Estradaserg attached a Rainbow Energy to Muk & Alolan Muk-GX.

    41. Estradaserg's Muk & Alolan Muk-GX had 1 damage counter(s) put on it from Rainbow Energy.

    42. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX is now Poisoned.

    43. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX is now Paralyzed.

    44. Estradaserg's Muk & Alolan Muk-GX used its Nasty Goo Mix GX attack.

    45. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX took 30 damage because it was Poisoned.

    46. It is now Spenchismo's turn (Turn #4).

    47. Spenchismo drew a card.

    48. Spenchismo played Wondrous Labyrinth {*}.

    49. Spenchismo played Max Potion.

    50. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX healed for 60.

    51. Spenchismo put Eevee onto the Bench.

    52. Spenchismo attached a Double Colorless Energy to Sylveon-GX.

    53. Spenchismo played Cynthia.

    54. Spenchismo drew a card.

    55. Spenchismo drew a card.

    56. Spenchismo drew a card.

    57. Spenchismo drew a card.

    58. Spenchismo drew a card.

    59. Spenchismo drew a card.

    60. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX took 10 damage because it was Poisoned.

    61. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX is no longer Paralyzed.

    62. It is now Estradaserg's turn (Turn #5).

    63. Estradaserg drew Cynthia.

    64. Estradaserg played Cynthia.

    65. Estradaserg drew Professor Sycamore.

    66. Estradaserg drew Grass Energy.

    67. Estradaserg drew Psychic Energy.

    68. Estradaserg drew Spell Tag.

    69. Estradaserg drew Grass Energy.

    70. Estradaserg drew Nest Ball.

    71. Estradaserg played Nest Ball.

    72. Estradaserg put Seviper onto the Bench.

    73. Estradaserg attached a Spell Tag to Muk & Alolan Muk-GX.

    74. Estradaserg attached a Psychic Energy to Muk & Alolan Muk-GX.

    75. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX took 20 damage because it was Poisoned.

    76. It is now Spenchismo's turn (Turn #6).

    77. Spenchismo drew a card.

    78. Spenchismo attached a Fairy Energy to Eevee.

    79. Spenchismo's Eevee used its Energy Evolution Ability.

    80. Spenchismo put Sylveon-GX onto the Bench.

    81. Spenchismo's Eevee evolved into Sylveon-GX.

    82. Spenchismo played Acerola.

    83. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX is no longer Poisoned.

    84. Sylveon-GX became Spenchismo's new Active Pokémon.

    85. Spenchismo put Eevee onto the Bench.

    86. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX used its Magical Ribbon attack.

    87. Spenchismo drew a card.

    88. Spenchismo drew a card.

    89. Spenchismo drew a card.

    90. It is now Estradaserg's turn (Turn #7).

    91. Estradaserg drew Seviper.

    92. Estradaserg put Seviper onto the Bench.

    93. Estradaserg attached a Grass Energy to Muk & Alolan Muk-GX.

    94. Estradaserg played Professor Sycamore.

    95. Estradaserg drew Shuckle-GX.

    96. Estradaserg drew Brock's Grit.

    97. Estradaserg drew Nest Ball.

    98. Estradaserg drew Spinarak.

    99. Estradaserg drew Poison Barb.

    100. Estradaserg drew Celebi & Venusaur-GX.

    101. Estradaserg drew Psychic Energy.

    102. Estradaserg played Nest Ball.

    103. Estradaserg put Seviper onto the Bench.

    104. Estradaserg put Shuckle-GX onto the Bench.

    105. It is now Spenchismo's turn (Turn #8).

    106. Spenchismo drew a card.

    107. Spenchismo attached a Bodybuilding Dumbbells to Sylveon-GX.

    108. Spenchismo attached a Double Colorless Energy to Sylveon-GX.

    109. Spenchismo played Crushing Hammer.

    110. Spenchismo flipped 1 coin(s), resulting in 0 heads and 1 tails, for Crushing Hammer.

    111. Spenchismo put Sylveon-GX onto the Bench.

    112. Spenchismo's Eevee evolved into Sylveon-GX.

    113. Spenchismo played Field Blower.

    114. Spenchismo played Team Skull Grunt.

    115. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX used Fairy Wind and did 110 damage to Estradaserg's Muk & Alolan Muk-GX.

    116. It is now Estradaserg's turn (Turn #9).

    117. Estradaserg drew Grass Energy.

    118. Estradaserg attached a Grass Energy to Muk & Alolan Muk-GX.

    119. Estradaserg attached a Poison Barb to Muk & Alolan Muk-GX.

    120. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX is now Poisoned.

    121. Estradaserg's Muk & Alolan Muk-GX used its Severe Poison attack.

    122. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX took 110 damage because it was Poisoned.

    123. It is now Spenchismo's turn (Turn #10).

    124. Spenchismo drew a card.

    125. Spenchismo attached a Fairy Energy to Sylveon-GX.

    126. Estradaserg's Muk & Alolan Muk-GX retreated.

    127. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX retreated.

    128. Spenchismo played Guzma.

    129. Shuckle-GX became Estradaserg's new Active Pokémon.

    130. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX is no longer Poisoned.

    131. Sylveon-GX became Spenchismo's new Active Pokémon.

    132. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX used its Magical Ribbon attack.

    133. Spenchismo drew a card.

    134. Spenchismo drew a card.

    135. Spenchismo drew a card.

    136. It is now Estradaserg's turn (Turn #11).

    137. Estradaserg drew Psychic Energy.

    138. Estradaserg attached a Psychic Energy to Shuckle-GX.

    139. Estradaserg's Shuckle-GX retreated.

    140. Muk & Alolan Muk-GX became Estradaserg's new Active Pokémon.

    141. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX is now Poisoned.

    142. Estradaserg's Muk & Alolan Muk-GX used its Severe Poison attack.

    143. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX took 110 damage because it was Poisoned.

    144. It is now Spenchismo's turn (Turn #12).

    145. Spenchismo drew a card.

    146. Spenchismo played Enhanced Hammer.

    147. Spenchismo played Crushing Hammer.

    148. Spenchismo flipped 1 coin(s), resulting in 0 heads and 1 tails, for Crushing Hammer.

    149. Spenchismo attached a Double Colorless Energy to Sylveon-GX.

    150. Spenchismo played Cynthia.

    151. Spenchismo drew a card.

    152. Spenchismo drew a card.

    153. Spenchismo drew a card.

    154. Spenchismo drew a card.

    155. Spenchismo drew a card.

    156. Spenchismo drew a card.

    157. Spenchismo played Pal Pad.

    158. Spenchismo played Max Potion.

    159. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX healed for 110.

    160. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX used Fairy Wind and did 110 damage to Estradaserg's Muk & Alolan Muk-GX.

    161. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX took 40 damage because it was Poisoned.

    162. It is now Estradaserg's turn (Turn #13).

    163. Estradaserg drew Grass Energy.

    164. Estradaserg attached a Grass Energy to Muk & Alolan Muk-GX.

    165. Estradaserg's Muk & Alolan Muk-GX used its Severe Poison attack.

    166. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX took 110 damage because it was Poisoned.

    167. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX is no longer Poisoned.

    168. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX was Knocked Out.

    169. Estradaserg took a Prize card.

    170. Estradaserg took a Prize card.

    171. Sylveon-GX became Spenchismo's new Active Pokémon.

    172. It is now Spenchismo's turn (Turn #14).

    173. Spenchismo drew a card.

    174. Estradaserg's Muk & Alolan Muk-GX retreated.

    175. Spenchismo played Guzma.

    176. Seviper became Estradaserg's new Active Pokémon.

    177. Spenchismo attached a Fairy Energy to Sylveon-GX.

    178. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX used its Magical Ribbon attack.

    179. Spenchismo drew a card.

    180. Spenchismo drew a card.

    181. Spenchismo drew a card.

    182. It is now Estradaserg's turn (Turn #***.

    183. Estradaserg drew Double Colorless Energy.

    184. Estradaserg attached a Double Colorless Energy to Seviper.

    185. Estradaserg's Seviper retreated.

    186. Muk & Alolan Muk-GX became Estradaserg's new Active Pokémon.

    187. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX is now Poisoned.

    188. Estradaserg's Muk & Alolan Muk-GX used its Severe Poison attack.

    189. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX took 110 damage because it was Poisoned.

    190. It is now Spenchismo's turn (Turn #16).

    191. Spenchismo drew a card.

    192. Spenchismo attached a Double Colorless Energy to Sylveon-GX.

    193. Spenchismo put Eevee onto the Bench.

    194. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX used Fairy Wind and did 110 damage to Estradaserg's Muk & Alolan Muk-GX.

    195. Estradaserg's Muk & Alolan Muk-GX was Knocked Out.

    196. Spenchismo took a Prize card.

    197. Spenchismo took a Prize card.

    198. Spenchismo took a Prize card.

    199. Shuckle-GX became Estradaserg's new Active Pokémon.

    200. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX took 40 damage because it was Poisoned.

    201. It is now Estradaserg's turn (Turn #17).

    202. Estradaserg drew Poison Barb.

    203. Estradaserg attached a Poison Barb to Shuckle-GX.

    204. Estradaserg played Brock's Grit.

    205. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX took 40 damage because it was Poisoned.

    206. It is now Spenchismo's turn (Turn #18).

    207. Spenchismo drew a card.

    208. Spenchismo put Sylveon-GX onto the Bench.

    209. Spenchismo's Eevee evolved into Sylveon-GX.

    210. Spenchismo attached a Fairy Energy to Sylveon-GX.

    211. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX retreated.

    212. Spenchismo played Switch.

    213. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX is no longer Poisoned.

    214. Sylveon-GX became Spenchismo's new Active Pokémon.

    215. Spenchismo played Pokémon Catcher.

    216. Spenchismo flipped 1 coin(s), resulting in 0 heads and 1 tails, for Pokémon Catcher.

    217. Spenchismo played Cynthia.

    218. Spenchismo drew a card.

    219. Spenchismo drew a card.

    220. Spenchismo drew a card.

    221. Spenchismo drew a card.

    222. Spenchismo drew a card.

    223. Spenchismo drew a card.

    224. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX used its Magical Ribbon attack.

    225. Spenchismo drew a card.

    226. Spenchismo drew a card.

    227. Spenchismo drew a card.

    228. It is now Estradaserg's turn (Turn #19).

    229. Estradaserg drew Psychic Energy.

    230. Estradaserg put Mewtwo & Mew-GX onto the Bench.

    231. Estradaserg attached a Psychic Energy to Mewtwo & Mew-GX.

    232. It is now Spenchismo's turn (Turn #20).

    233. Spenchismo drew a card.

    234. Spenchismo put Eevee onto the Bench.

    235. Spenchismo attached a Double Colorless Energy to Sylveon-GX.

    236. Spenchismo played Acerola.

    237. Spenchismo attached a Bodybuilding Dumbbells to Sylveon-GX.

    238. Spenchismo put Eevee onto the Bench.

    239. Spenchismo played Crushing Hammer.

    240. Spenchismo flipped 1 coin(s), resulting in 0 heads and 1 tails, for Crushing Hammer.

    241. Spenchismo played Crushing Hammer.

    242. Spenchismo flipped 1 coin(s), resulting in 0 heads and 1 tails, for Crushing Hammer.

    243. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX used its Magical Ribbon attack.

    244. Spenchismo drew a card.

    245. Spenchismo drew a card.

    246. Spenchismo drew a card.

    247. It is now Estradaserg's turn (Turn #21).

    248. Estradaserg drew Psychic Energy.

    249. Estradaserg attached a Psychic Energy to Mewtwo & Mew-GX.

    250. It is now Spenchismo's turn (Turn #22).

    251. Spenchismo drew a card.

    252. Spenchismo played Plumeria.

    253. Spenchismo played Pokémon Catcher.

    254. Spenchismo flipped 1 coin(s), resulting in 1 heads and 0 tails, for Pokémon Catcher.

    255. Estradaserg's Shuckle-GX retreated.

    256. Mewtwo & Mew-GX became Estradaserg's new Active Pokémon.

    257. Spenchismo attached a Fairy Energy to Eevee.

    258. Spenchismo's Eevee used its Energy Evolution Ability.

    259. Spenchismo put Sylveon-GX onto the Bench.

    260. Spenchismo's Eevee evolved into Sylveon-GX.

    261. Spenchismo put Sylveon-GX onto the Bench.

    262. Spenchismo's Eevee evolved into Sylveon-GX.

    263. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX used Fairy Wind and did 110 damage to Estradaserg's Mewtwo & Mew-GX.

    264. It is now Estradaserg's turn (Turn #23).

    265. Estradaserg drew Grass Energy.

    266. Estradaserg attached a Grass Energy to Mewtwo & Mew-GX.

    267. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX is now Poisoned.

    268. Estradaserg's Mewtwo & Mew-GX used its Triple Poison attack.

    269. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX took 60 damage because it was Poisoned.

    270. It is now Spenchismo's turn (Turn #24).

    271. Spenchismo drew a card.

    272. Spenchismo attached a Double Colorless Energy to Sylveon-GX.

    273. Spenchismo played Guzma.

    274. Estradaserg's Mewtwo & Mew-GX retreated.

    275. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX retreated.

    276. Shuckle-GX became Estradaserg's new Active Pokémon.

    277. Spenchismo's Sylveon-GX is no longer Poisoned.

    278. Sylveon-GX became Spenchismo's new Active Pokémon.

 

 

Edited by Mod_GuruLot
spoiler tags included to reduce the post size, title updated

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Mod_Elderberry

Hello Trainer Estradaserg,


Thank you for your bug report. I have submitted it to the proper channels for review.

I have also updated the title of this thread.

 

Thank you again for your bug report.

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
armlessturtle

You seem to be using Poison Barb. I believe the counter poison it does overwrites severe poison, and is not a bug. Here is a similar ruling on Koga's Trap.

 

Q. If I had used Muk & Alolan Muk GX's "Severe Poison" attack that places extra Poison damage counters and in the next turn use Koga's Trap, do they still place the extra Poison damage?
A. No, they don't. The new, normal Poison Special Condition replaces the old Severe Poison Special Condition. (Unbroken Bonds FAQ; May 2, 2019 TPCi Rules Team)

  • Upvote 1

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites
Mod_GuruLot
11 hours ago, armlessturtle said:

You seem to be using Poison Barb. I believe the counter poison it does overwrites severe poison, and is not a bug. Here is a similar ruling on Koga's Trap.

 

Q. If I had used Muk & Alolan Muk GX's "Severe Poison" attack that places extra Poison damage counters and in the next turn use Koga's Trap, do they still place the extra Poison damage?
A. No, they don't. The new, normal Poison Special Condition replaces the old Severe Poison Special Condition. (Unbroken Bonds FAQ; May 2, 2019 TPCi Rules Team)

 

Hello @armlessturtle

 

Thank you for helping out and sharing your thoughts on this! :) 

 

I hope the fellow trainer @Estradaserg finds it useful. 

Share this post


Link to post
Share on other sites

×
×
  • Create New...